It happened at a regional Golf Croquet event at Tega Cay in South Carolina, with teams from North Carolina, South Carolina, Florida, and Georgia. The Quadway hoops were provided by Simon Jenkins, the US agent for both Quadway hoops and Terminator mallets.
The trial was significant because the predominant construction method for courts in the US is sand-based or a sand-based root zone mix--which is not the case in most other croquet-playing countries. The question, in Damon's words, was "How well do these Kiwi-developed hoops play in our American sand pit?"
It turns out that they play very well, but it was the ease of resetting the hoops for different widths that sold David Maloof, top-ranked American croquet pro and recent finalist in the world championship, on buying them for his summer venues in the North Carolina mountains.
The assessment that it is the most difficult hoop to run has been thoroughly verified. That fact alone qualifies it as the ultimate "test" of relative skill in major events for top-ranked players. (That issue can be effectively addressed only in three categories: hoops, terrain, and "advanced" rules that call for lift shots.)
The sets are expensive and costly to ship from New Zealand. But their labor-saving and accuracy attributes may justify their purchase by local clubs.
The dibber tool, an essential part of the system, must be used to made the precise hole to receive the rectangular carrot of the hoop legs. The dibber eliminates the need to pound each wicket into place. This pounding in of hoops is the traditional way they have been set, and over time it results in bowing the legs out and marring the finish of the cross bar.
The dibber also makes it easy to set all the hoops with uniform widths and within tournament specification in a snap. (By eliminating the outside pressure from clamping, the hoop width tends to remain constant, as the current practice at most facilities with conventional hoops places pressure from a clamp that releases and causes the width to change or revert to the manufactured shape over the course of a day.)
David Maloof reported the performance of the hoops "surprisingly good in the wet soil." (There had been lots of rain on the courts.) "Even when the hoops loosened a bit, they still rejected mediocre shots. I had tested the hoops in soft soil playing Association Croquet, and my first impression was that they were not much more difficult than our 3-fin hoops, (the so-called "Super Hoops" conventionally set for top-level events on America's sand-based courts) but then I noticed how our club members were struggling with them. The bottom line is that they don't react well to bad swings."
David Maloof's videos from Linville demonstrate how he's training his club members to run these hoops, with the one set he bought for himself. And if you can run these hoops well, presumably you won't have any trouble other hoops, anywhere.
The hoops are ideal for top-level competitions
The hoops are ideal for top-level competitions
On Day Two, US team captain Erv Peterson wrote, "On these hoops, you have to be right in front--I keep telling the guys perfect pioneers and hoop approaches from one foot! You cannot bang through them, it's an immediate reject if you are off slightly."
Player Gene Raymond commented at Tega Cay, "They require some time to become accustomed to the characteristics and ultimately may make you a better shooter. If they are the international standard for hoops, then we may want their use in the US to be more widespread."
Robert Hurst of South Carolina elaborated, " I was extremely skeptical that the Quadway hoops would hold up in soft, wet sand. I was impressed to see that they did. The hoops are bouncy, and that leads to rejections at angles, and shot end points that I have really just never seen. I thought they were fair and really couldn't be bullied--they gave a bit but still rejected. Without perfect pace, they were hard to jaws."
Another player commented, "For Golf Croquet--in wet conditions on a sand based lawn--they put up as much resistance as any hoop I've played, including super hoops."
Matthew Essick, one of the youngest of US champions, opined, "I was against using these hoops prior to the event, due to a fear of wear and tear throughout the course of a day causing the hoops to become loose. Despite the weather, they stayed firm and consistent. Now I'm a very big fan of the Quadway hoops."
Jeff Soo, perenially one of the top-ranked players of the US team, reported, "Since we didn't do a side-to-side test my conclusions are tentative, but I do think even in wet sandy soil the hoops were more likely to reject gentle and moderately-paced shots than standard hoops. Deliberate jaws attempts were difficult. There is a springiness to the hoops that seems to offset the softness of the turf (at least to some extent). Having played a couple of events in New Zealand with these hoops I know they are challenging in firm soil but I was pleasantly surprised at how well they performed here.
Bidencope summed up, "The Quadway gets a thumbs up for playing well in our sand pit!! But the single biggest benefit is that they can be engineered to be wider for beginners -- this is huge if you want more beginners playing the game!"
Damon Bidencope was the first "international player" to be hired in America as a pro, at Meadowwood Resort in Northern California in the mid 80's. He is now in real estate in South Carolina. David Maloof is a working pro at country clubs in the mountain of North Carolina in the summer and in Florida in the winter. Maloof narrowly lost the last world championship played in America in a five-match marathon at the National Croquet Center in 2016.